(NAME-MCE) Critics say district discriminated against its own diversity advocate

[Michelle Cromwell]

This is truly unfortunate.

In no way trivializing the situation but applying a conflict  
analyst's lens I am trying to look at all perspectives. This is in an  
effort to understand the actions of the School Board. It seems that  
they are indicating that the necessary trust needed to break the  
structural "white wall" and their vulnerability was not established  
on their end. Sometimes in doing the diversity work it is easier to  
connect with those partial to our objectives, but so much harder to  
truly win over the unsupportive (is that a word?) stakeholder. And as  
the saying goes "That's when people get funny".

As Ms. Bennett-Roberts pointed out this is so much bigger than her. I  
hope that her skills and knowledge are utilized, supported and  
appreciated elsewhere.




Michelle Cromwell, PhD
Assistant Professor Social /Political Systems
Center Associate Multicultural Education
President, Multicultural Village Inc.

Baraka Bashad (May the blessings be)




************************************************************************ 
*************************************





On Jul 9, 2008, at 5:31 PM, Anselmo Villanueva wrote:

>
>
> July 8, 2008
>
> Critics say district discriminated against its own diversity advocate
>
> The sudden dismissal of a Virginia district's minority liaison has
> angered black community members and other supporters of the diversity
> advocate. "We were appalled," said Reginald A. Early, president of the
> local NAACP chapter. "There is no credible reason for her contract not
> to be renewed, given that she was doing exactly what she was hired to
> do. It just doesn't make sense. There's a disconnect somewhere."
>
> http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/07/08/ 
> AR2008070802690.html?hpid=moreheadlines
>
> LOUDOUN COUNTY
>
> Minority Groups Decry Ouster of School Advocate
> 	
> Loudoun County's minority community is criticizing school officials
> for failing to renew the contract of the district's first supervisor
> for outreach.
>
> Despite months of lobbying from teachers, parents and organizations
> representing minorities, the school system ended its contract last
> month with Beverly Bennett-Roberts, who was hired nearly three years
> ago to lead the district's diversity efforts.
>
> Supporters of Bennett-Roberts blame discrimination and the school
> system's desire to maintain the status quo for her firing.
> Bennett-Roberts and her attorney, Michael Miller, said the
> termination, which occurred several months after her only evaluation,
> was flawed and failed to follow the school district's written
> administrative policies.
>
> "We were appalled," said Reginald A. Early, president of the Loudoun
> County NAACP. "There is no credible reason for her contract not to be
> renewed, given that she was doing exactly what she was hired to do. It
> just doesn't make sense. There's a disconnect somewhere."
>
> Privacy rules prevent the district from commenting on personnel
> issues, schools spokesman Wayde B. Byard said, adding that the
> district maintains its commitment to diversity.
>
> An advertisement for the job has been posted on the school system's  
> Web site.
>
> Early and others in the community are worried that the district's
> decision will impede progress made during Bennett-Roberts's tenure and
> could have a negative effect on its relationship with minorities.
>
> In her evaluation in February, a copy of which she provided to The
> Washington Post, school officials said Bennett-Roberts had an
> "unwillingness or inability" to stay within her job description,
> failed to alert her supervisor of negative perceptions of the school
> district, failed to follow directions from her supervisor, provided
> internal e-mails to people outside the school system without
> permission of the originator and communicated with outsiders to
> undermine or cast doubt on equity efforts.
>
> "You have failed to develop the trust necessary to build a cooperative
> relationship between outside sources and the school system," the
> evaluation said. "You have demonstrated unethical behavior by
> providing information to outside sources for the purpose of
> discrediting Loudoun County Public Schools."
>
> Edward Bourne, a member of the school system's minority-student
> achievement advisory committee, said that from the community's
> perspective, Bennett-Roberts's performance was "phenomenal." Many
> people don't think the school system is being transparent about the
> issue, he said. "I think there's a lack of trust there that really
> needs to be addressed," he said.
>
> When Bennett-Roberts came to Loudoun in November 2005, there was no
> road map. Her job was a newly created position designed to focus on
> outreach to various parent advisory groups, coordinating parent
> volunteers and working with principals and schools to develop equity
> teams.
>
> More than 30 percent of the school system's 54,047 students are
> minorities, 2007-08 figures showed.
>
> Bennett-Roberts started a monthly diversity-training program and held
> several workshops and symposiums that drew hundreds of parents. She
> documented her experiences in a six-page report, including
> observations that there are no women of color leading any of the
> district's secondary schools and that many minority students and
> parents think they are not noticed. She recommended that the district
> undergo a "cultural audit."
>
> Many minority parents said that for the first time, they thought they
> had a voice and an advocate in the school system. Nearly two dozen
> people from diverse backgrounds spoke in support of Bennett-Roberts at
> School Board meetings in April, May and June.
>
> Bennett-Roberts and her attorney say the school district violated its
> evaluation policies by not having preliminary discussions about her
> performance, and setting goals and objectives.
>
> Bennett-Roberts said she was notified in December that she was in
> danger of receiving an unsatisfactory evaluation. In February, she was
> told that she had not met the district's standard for progress and
> that her contract might not be renewed.
>
> "I never had anything but the December meeting," said Bennett-Roberts,
> who has held similar positions in Baltimore and Minnesota. "I was just
> baffled by this whole process."
>
> She and her attorney said they have not ruled out a lawsuit.
>
> "This is bigger than me. This isn't just my fight," she said. "This is
> about an organization that needs to change. Until they turn the mirror
> on themselves, there will be more Beverlys."
>
> _______________________________________________
> This is a mailing of the National Association for Multicultural  
> Education -
> (NAME) Listserv list - www.nameorg.org. The materials included  
> reflect diverse perspectives of NAME Listserv participants and do  
> not necessarily reflect a position of the National Association for  
> Multicultural Education. If you would like to subscribe (or  
> unsubscribe)to this listserv go to http://mail.nameorg.org/mailman/ 
> listinfo/name-mce_nameorg.org. You can read all past postings in  
> the archives at http://mail.nameorg.org/pipermail/name- 
> mce_nameorg.org/
>
>
>
> Name-mce mailing list
> Name-mce at nameorg.org
> http://mail.nameorg.org/mailman/listinfo/name-mce_nameorg.org
>